ANAC logo
Red Rule
Associated New American Colleges
At the Woodrow Wilson
National Fellowship Foundation

Data Exchange
ANAC Directory
ANAC Home Page
Faculty Work Project
Listservs & Forums
Upcoming ANAC Events
Help Net
ANAC Bulletin
ANAC Bulletin Masthead
Red Rule Winter 2002 Edition

ANAC Commentary


"L
esser-known undergraduate institutions often do a better job than the brand name schools in preparing less confident students for life. Their professors demand as much as the Nobel laureates at Big Name U., but the academic competition tends to be friendlier and the teaching better. When it comes time for real life, that is, graduate school or a first job, the graduate of the college with the lower average SAT score is still going to be in good shape."

—Jay Mathews,
   Senior Education Writer at the Washington Post

 

President Bobby Fong, "Learning Well the Best Revenge"


Excerpts from new Butler University President Bobby Fong, in connection with his February 9 inaugural: "Education is not a panacea, but it is integral to our efforts to combat terrorism worldwide as well as within our own country. Citizens need wide-ranging factual information to make wise decisions. Education leaders need to ensure that all of our students have the knowledge they need to see through the hateful claims of those who would legitimize terrorism. Students also need, not just information, but guidance in how to assess information. Education that consists solely of information transmission too quickly resembles indoctrination.

Throughout world history education has been a beacon. In this tumultuous time, we need to find ways to focus its beam as a source of hope. It's our job, whether as educators, parents, or members of the community, to teach all children that every person has an innate worth to be respected and protected. We must encourage them to speak out when they see authorities falling short of their ideals and to act responsibly to make the changes they see are needed. Students learn these things by study and dialogue, but, more importantly, they learn by experiencing them. We need to encourage students to participate in internships, volunteer service, and study abroad programs, which introduce them to other cultures and ideas. Students also learn through observation. All of us need to consciously live out the values and ideals that we espouse, reminding ourselves that, in everything we do, the next generation is watching."

Pew Research Center Poll Reveals Contrasting Post-September 11 Views of America

A recent Pew Research Center poll of "influentials"—leaders in business, government, the media, and culture—in 24 countries on five continents reveals sharp contrasts in perceptions Americans have of U.S. policies and their impacts and how differently the U.S. is seen in other parts of the world, even among Europeans. The results demonstrate starkly the necessity for expanding international education in the United States and just how daunting the challenge is to find revenge through learning, to paraphrase Bobby Fong. Consider these findings in the Pew poll:

  • Only 18% of Americans said U.S. policies and actions were a "major cause" of the terrorist attacks on September 11; 58% of non-American respondents disagreed, saying they were a major cause of the attacks.
  • 42% of non-Americans said the United States is overreacting to the attacks; no Americans said the U.S. is overacting.
  • 70% of Americans said the U.S. is cooperating with other countries and taking their interests into account in the fight against terrorism; only 33% of non-Americans agreed.
  • 70% of non-Americans said people in their countries have a good opinion of the United States (81% of Western Europeans, 52% of those from Islamic countries).
  • 52% of Americans say the world likes the U.S. because of the good the U.S. does around the world; only 21% of non-Americans agreed (only 12% of Latin Americans agreed). Everyone agreed that the U.S. is liked for its democratic ideals and because the U.S. is the "land of opportunity."
  • Only 32% of Americans said that America's scientific and technological innovations are a major reason for U.S. popularity; 63% of Europeans and 86% of those from the Middle East said U.S. science and technology are a major reason the U.S. is admired.
  • 70% of Americans believe U.S. support for Israel and 88% believe U.S. power are primary causes of hostility to the U.S. around the world; only 29% of non-Americans agreed that Israel is the cause and barely half said the rest of the world resents U.S. power, but 52% (61% of Europeans) said the U.S. is disliked because our leadership of the global economy has made the rich richer and the poor poorer around the world.


Gerald Whittington, CFO at Elon University (at left), prepares to lead
fellow ANAC CFO's on an Elon campus tour. More than 60%
of Elon students study abroad.

Jay Mathews on "Choosing the College that fits Best"

Jay Mathews, a senior education writer at the Washington Post, wrote a column with the above title in early February. In the column he tests the hypothesis of George Mason University economist Walter E. Williams who maintains that "high school students should not apply to—and their parents should not pay tuition for—colleges whose average SAT scores are 200 points or more higher than their's." Williams' primary concern is the experience of minority students who have alarming drop out rates at such institutions. One study found, for example, that 70% of African American students failed to graduate at the University of California at Berkeley, "their SATs 52 points above the national average but 229 points below the Berkeley average."

Mathews cites other sources that point out that many low-income students fall behind in grade school and never "make it to the starting line" and that the SAT was designed only to predict first year college grades-not motivation, work ethic, determination, or love of learning. Mathews concludes that developing student self-confidence in a supportive academic environment may be a critical factor in achieving high graduation rates among students in lower SAT tiers, especially low-income students—in effect overcoming the psychological burden that low SAT or ACT scores may represent.

Mathews' punch line, "lesser-known undergraduate institutions often do a better job than the brand name schools in preparing less confident students for life. Their professors demand as much as the Nobel laureates at Big Name U., but the academic competition tends to be friendlier and the teaching better. When it comes time for real life, that is, graduate school or a first job, the graduate of the college with the lower average SAT score is still going to be in good shape." Summing up, Mathews quotes Harvard historian Stephan Thernstrom, "I suppose if I thought that a Harvard diploma was a priceless asset in life, I might want my kid to have one even if his SATs were 200 points below the mean. But I don't think that at all."


Sunset over Cardinal Stadium, North Central College's new SafePlay Plus
synthetic surface facility that will seat more than 15,000 and is to serve
as the home field for the Chicago Fire professional soccer team
during the renovation of Soldier Field next year.


  back to the top  |  e-mail us  |  anac bulletin home